5 Comments
User's avatar
Rhiannon Johnson's avatar

I totally agree with everything you said about The Dream Hotel.

Expand full comment
Emma's avatar

I’m glad I’m not alone!

Expand full comment
Daniel Puzzo's avatar

A belated happy birthday!

Nice roundup - it's refreshing to see more honest and less overly positive reviews. I see some reviewers giving 5 stars to everything they read, but with your more discerning writeups, I feel less pressure to add to my TBR.

However, I think you've convinced me to give The Wager a go. I see it all the time just staring at me in bookshops, saying 'buy me!' One of my reading resolutions this year was to give audiobooks more of a go, but I've struggled with them.

Highly recommend The Warmth of Other Suns, though it's not exactly light reading. If you want some exhilarating non-fiction narrative, and it sounds like it might be similar to The Wager, check out Long Lost Log: Diary of a Virgin Sailor my Mick Chapman. It was a highly entertaining adventure and I'm eager to read the sequel.

Expand full comment
Emma's avatar

Thank you!

I feel that reviewing I used to shy away from anything negative because I didn’t want to be that person, but then myself was getting bored of reading glowing reviews of mediocre books.

It’s also helped me step back and actually think whether I liked the book or the fact I read a hyped book - if that makes sense?

I actually have warmth of other suns on my bookshelf but as you said it’s heavy that I’m waiting for the right time to give a read.

The wager was great on audio, I have bought the paperback as a gift and it has lots of maps and pictures which I would have loved to have seen whilst reading though. So pros to either choice!

Expand full comment
Daniel Puzzo's avatar

My TBR list is, like many others, sprawling so it's comforting to see books I was on the fence about get a less than glowing review. It's not always so much the lower rating itself, but more the specific things a reviewer says that put me off and convince me I'm less likely to enjoy it. If I'm reading an Amazon review, there are negatives I can overlook knowing it's very subjective but others that ring alarm bells because I can see how it'll drive me nuts.

I'll go with the Wager in paperback then.

Expand full comment